Chapter 17 - The Trial of Gideon Vale
Gideon Vale’s trial began eight months later.
By then the Carter homestead looked different.
New roof.
Repaired barn.
Same modest house.
Sarah refused to build anything grand.
Noah accused her of being boring.
She accepted the charge.
Vale faced federal fraud and bribery conspiracy.
The prosecution’s case was strong but complicated.
Documents.
Surveyors.
Bank clerks.
Aaron Flint.
Jonas Gray.
Sheriff Trent.
Commissioner Sloan.
Benjamin’s records.
Arthur Hale’s diary after it was recovered from a Vale attorney who attempted to destroy it.
Every witness had flaws.
Defense lawyers exploited each one.
Jonas had taken money.
Trent had hidden evidence.
Aaron had lied.
Henry Bell betrayed Benjamin.
Even Benjamin signed the original option and stamped questionable deeds.
The defense argued the entire scandal was a collection of corrupt small players blaming the wealthy man at the center.
For days, it worked.
Then Gideon Vale testified.
His lawyers advised against it.
He insisted.
Perhaps pride.
Perhaps belief he could control one final story.
The prosecutor asked:
“Did you authorize payments to public officials?”
“I authorized consulting expenses.”
“Did you know some were officials?”
“Yes.”
“Did you expect favorable treatment?”
Vale paused.
“Sometimes.”
A murmur spread.
His own attorney closed his eyes.
Then:
“Did you order Caleb Voss to threaten Benjamin Carter?”
“I instructed Voss to recover company documents.”
“By force?”
“I told him not to return without them.”
Sarah felt cold.
There.
The language powerful men used to avoid imagining consequences.
“Did you know Voss was violent?”
“Yes.”
“Did you know Benjamin was armed?”
“Yes.”
“And you sent Voss anyway?”
“Yes.”
“Did you intend Benjamin to die?”
“No.”
“Did you care enough to prevent it?”
Vale looked toward Sarah.
Long silence.
“No.”
That answer destroyed something.
Perhaps his defense.
Perhaps only the final lie he still carried.
The jury convicted Vale on multiple fraud, bribery and obstruction counts.
Not Benjamin’s murder.
Voss later pleaded guilty to second-degree murder rather than face trial.
His account:
He intercepted Benjamin.
Demanded the survey evidence.
Benjamin fired a warning shot.
Voss fired back deliberately.
Benjamin fell.
Voss then staged the horse accident with assistance from men who believed they were only moving a body for “company reasons.”
Ugly.
Human.
Prosecutors could support enough of it.
Sarah and Noah attended sentencing.
Voss looked at Noah once.
The boy did not look away.
The judge imposed a long prison sentence.
Afterward, reporters surrounded Sarah.
She hated them.
One asked:
“Mrs. Carter, do you feel justice has been served?”
She thought of Benjamin.
Isaac.
Arthur Hale.
People harmed and never restored.
“Partly.”
The reporter seemed disappointed.
They wanted a triumphant sentence.
She gave them truth.
“Some things can be punished. They can’t be undone.”
Noah squeezed her hand.
Outside, Elias waited with horses.
Sarah smiled.
“You could’ve come inside.”
“It was your family’s day.”
“You’re becoming annoyingly respectful.”
“I’ve practiced.”
Noah climbed onto his horse.
“He’s lying. He hates courtrooms.”
Elias laughed.
They rode home.
At sunset, Sarah stopped near Dry Creek Road.
The place Benjamin died.
She had avoided it for years.
Now she dismounted.
No monument.
Just grass and stone.
Noah stood beside her.
“Was it here?”
“Yes.”
Elias remained farther back.
Sarah appreciated it.
Noah asked:
“What do we do?”
“I don’t know.”
They stood silently.
Then Noah placed one peppermint on a rock.
Sarah laughed through tears.
“Why?”
“He gave me those.”
Simple.
Not evidence.
Not history.
A memory unconnected to corruption.
That mattered.
They rode on.
When the Carter homestead appeared, Elias slowed.
Sarah looked at him.
“What?”
“I need to go home tomorrow.”
“To your father?”
“Yes.”
“For how long?”
“I don’t know.”
Sarah’s chest tightened.
Red Willow politics had not disappeared because Vale went to prison.
Jonas faced council judgment.
Matthew was aging.
Elias had responsibilities.
Sarah understood.
She hated understanding.
Noah asked:
“You’re coming back?”
Elias looked at Sarah first.
Then Noah.
“If I’m welcome.”
Noah said:
“You are.”
Sarah raised an eyebrow.
“Apparently my vote doesn’t matter.”
Elias smiled.
“It matters most.”
Sarah looked at the house.
Benjamin’s letter.
Love someone else if you can.
She was not ready to promise anything.
But she was ready not to hide.
“Come back,” she said.
Elias’s expression changed.
Not dramatically.
Just enough.
“I will.”
Then Noah groaned.
“Are you two going to start acting strange?”
Sarah stared.
Elias laughed.
And for once, the biggest future mystery in Noah’s life was not buried evidence or murder.
May you like
![92 The Girl They Called Broke Was a Billionaire’s Daughter—But Her Father’s Arrival Exposed a Secret Powerful People Had Buried for Years]](https://cdn.treeiq.biz/site_590/2026/11/clone-0-0915d882-53d7-4d17-b43a-a010ca1a1068.webp)
It was adults falling in love.
He considered this deeply unfair.
