Chapter 9 - Before Amanda Met JacobThat evening, Judith and Jacob sat at table nine.

The ballroom was empty now. Without flowers, music, and two hundred guests, the hidden table looked almost ordinary.

Jacob turned the place card between his fingers.

MRS. JUDITH EMERSON.

“I didn’t know she moved you here,” he said.

“You did not ask where I was seated.”

“I assumed family table.”

“Assumptions have been expensive for you.”

He accepted the blow.

Judith had brought Harold’s 2019 letter. She placed it between them.

“Your father warned Thomas Mercer away from you.”

Jacob read it again. “I don’t remember Dad telling me.”

“He probably thought he was protecting you.”

“Like you do.”

Judith looked at him.

Jacob’s voice was tired, not hostile. “You pay, you fix, you decide what information I can handle. Then you’re surprised I make decisions without telling you.”

“You are comparing my paying for your wedding with your entering a locked safe.”

“No. I’m saying both of us have spent years pretending our pattern is normal.”

Judith felt anger rise.

“I did not create your nine-hundred-thousand-dollar guarantee.”

“No.”

“I did not make you sign detached pages.”

“No.”

“I did not make you lie about the safe.”

“No.”

“Then be careful where you distribute responsibility.”

Jacob set down the place card.

“I am responsible. I’m also telling you why I wanted the transfer so badly. I wanted one thing from this family that felt like mine before you decided whether I deserved it.”

The words struck deeper than Amanda’s accusations because Jacob was not using them as weapons.

Judith looked around Hollow Creek.

She and Harold had bought the failing vineyard forty-one years earlier with borrowed money and impossible confidence. Jacob had grown up among barrels and harvest crews, but ownership had always remained something his parents might someday grant him.

“I thought conditions made gifts safer,” she said.

“For whom?”

Judith almost answered him.

Then she understood.

“For me.”

Jacob nodded.

She touched Harold’s ring.

“That does not excuse what you did.”

“I know.”

“And acknowledging my mistake does not erase yours.”

“I know that too.”

For the first time since the wedding, they were speaking without bargaining.

Jacob opened his laptop.

“My lawyer told me to search my own records for anything involving Mercer, Sterling Crest, or Hollow Creek.”

He had found an email from 2019 after seeing Harold’s letter.

The sender was Thomas Mercer.

Mr. Emerson, good speaking with you briefly in Napa. Your family’s vineyard has unusual hospitality potential. If succession ever creates an opening, I would welcome a conversation.

Jacob had replied with one sentence.

My parents are not selling.

Two months later, Thomas wrote again.

Circumstances change.

Jacob never answered.

Judith studied the dates.

“Amanda knew about these messages?”

“I don’t know.”

“Search her name.”

He did.

The earliest email from Amanda Mercer appeared in March 2024, months before their first date. She had contacted Jacob about an industry panel.

Judith read the opening lines.

My father suggested you as someone who understands legacy businesses. I’m organizing a discussion about family-owned hospitality companies and would love your perspective.

Jacob stared at the screen.

“I forgot he introduced us.”

“You told me you met through a conference.”

“We did. I didn’t remember her father was the connection.”

Judith refused to say what both were thinking.

An introduction was not a conspiracy.

The email continued.

I know Hollow Creek by reputation. My family has admired the property for years.

Jacob closed his eyes.

“She told me later she’d never paid attention to the vineyard before we were together.”

“That could have meant personally.”

“You’re defending her?”

“I’m defending facts from our anger.”

His phone rang.

Thomas Mercer.

Jacob looked at Judith.

She said, “Your attorney?”

“Listening.”

He answered and placed the call on speaker after advising Thomas that counsel was present.

Thomas sounded composed.

“Jacob, this has become unnecessarily ugly.”

“My mother’s signatures were forged.”

“That is a serious accusation.”

“It’s a serious document.”

“I suggest everyone stop using inflammatory language until specialists review it.”

Judith recognized the practiced calm of a man accustomed to expensive disputes.

Thomas continued, “Sterling Crest remains willing to resolve matters commercially. A smaller membership transfer and a twelve-year hospitality lease could stabilize the financing.”

Judith mouthed no.

Jacob said, “Hollow Creek isn’t mine to lease.”

“It was expected to become partly yours.”

“Expected isn’t owned.”

A pause.

Thomas changed tactics.

“Your mother has spent your entire adult life keeping you at the children’s table.”

Jacob glanced at table nine.

“No,” he said. “Yesterday my wife put my mother there.”

Thomas exhaled.

“You are emotional.”

“I’m learning that doesn’t make me wrong.”

Judith looked at him.

Thomas’s voice hardened slightly. “If the deal fails, your guarantee remains. Amanda’s company will fail. Your marriage may fail. Your mother will still have her vineyard. Consider who carries the cost of her principles.”

Jacob gripped the phone.

“Did you ask Amanda to contact me in 2024 because of Hollow Creek?”

Silence.

“Thomas?”

“I suggested a professional connection.”

“Because of the vineyard?”

“I knew who your family was.”

“Did Amanda?”

Another pause.

“Yes.”

Judith felt no triumph.

Jacob looked ill.

Thomas continued quickly. “Knowing your background does not mean she married you for property.”

“I didn’t ask that.”

“No, but your mother will.”

Judith spoke for the first time.

“I haven’t.”

Thomas went silent.

Judith leaned toward the phone. “Harold told you in 2019 not to use our son as a route around us.”

“That was Harold’s interpretation.”

“And what is yours?”

“That Hollow Creek has been trapped by sentiment for decades.”

Judith smiled without warmth.

“Then you still want exactly what he refused.”

Thomas ended the call.

Jacob stared at the dark phone.

A message appeared seconds later from Amanda.

DAD SHOULD NEVER HAVE TOLD YOU I KNEW.

Jacob read it aloud.

The sentence did not prove why she loved him.

May you like

92 The Girl They Called Broke Was a Billionaire’s Daughter—But Her Fathe...

91 A Cruel Hotel Manager Fired a Receptionist for Defending a Poor Old G...

90 On Christmas Eve, My Daughter-in-Law Stole $12,000 From My Card—Then...

But it proved she had lied about how their story began.

And for Jacob, that lie was suddenly larger than the money between them.