Chapter 9 - What Arthur Asked Them to DoArthur’s final recording lasted nineteen minutes.

Maya listened twice.

Chloe listened three times.

Vanessa could not make it through once without leaving the room.

Arthur spoke slowly, breath weakened by illness.

“I spent my career designing beautiful things for people who sometimes cared more about owning them than understanding them. I fear I brought that disease home.”

Maya sat on the floor beside the white wings.

Arthur continued.

“Maya, you create because making something is how you understand the world. Chloe, you perform because being seen is how you understand your place in it. Neither is morally superior.”

Chloe whispered, “Thank you.”

Maya nudged her shoulder.

Arthur went on.

“The problem begins when Maya assumes being talented makes her emotionally right, and when Chloe assumes being overlooked gives her permission to take.”

Both sisters looked at each other.

“Rude,” Chloe muttered.

Maya almost smiled.

Then Arthur’s tone changed.

“Vanessa loves through protection. I love through preparation. Both can become control. If I am gone, do not turn my estate into a final referendum on whom I loved most.”

Vanessa covered her face.

“I have made that mistake already,” she whispered.

Arthur spoke about Bennett Atelier.

He wanted it to survive only if it became more transparent.

He wanted independent accounting.

Written creator royalties.

Employee representation.

No family member controlling more than forty percent alone.

He admitted that his draft restructuring had not been finalized because Adrian kept warning him of tax consequences and litigation risk.

“I delayed because I thought I had more time.”

Maya’s throat tightened.

Arthur did not romanticize himself.

That hurt and helped.

Near the end, he said:

“If the Halloween crown becomes part of this fight, destroy the importance of the crown.”

Chloe laughed through tears.

“Dad.”

“I mean it. A prize is useful when it recognizes work. It becomes poison when people use it to measure love, legitimacy, or inheritance.”

Maya thought of Chloe stealing wings.

Vanessa buying influence.

Adrian paying judges.

All around one crystal object worth maybe twelve thousand dollars and emotionally worth far more.

Arthur continued.

“If you want to honor me, make the competition honest enough that a stranger can beat you.”

Maya paused the recording.

Chloe looked at her.

“Elena.”

“Yes.”

They already knew what to do.

The next day, Maya and Chloe jointly requested that Marcus void the existing gala result and rerun final judging using an independent panel with full authorship verification.

Vanessa agreed.

Marcus smiled when they told him.

“I was hoping you’d get there.”

Chloe narrowed her eyes.

“You could’ve suggested it.”

“Then you would have been following another adult’s solution.”

“Annoyingly wise.”

“I’m fifty-five. It’s one of the few compensations.”

The gala board approved the rerun.

All finalists would be invited back two weeks later.

Original scores discarded.

Judges replaced.

Contestants required to document authorship or commission agreements.

Chloe withdrew her white-wing costume.

But she did not withdraw from the competition.

“I want to make something,” she told Maya.

Maya stared.

“You?”

“Try not to sound horrified.”

“What do you know how to make?”

“Apparently nothing.”

“Good starting point.”

Chloe rolled her eyes.

Then hesitated.

“Will you teach me?”

Maya almost said no.

Teaching the person who stole her work felt perverse.

But Arthur’s recording echoed.

A stranger can beat you.

Maybe a stepsister could learn beside you.

“I’ll teach you construction,” Maya said.

“Not design.”

“Fair.”

Chloe smiled.

For the next twelve days, Bennett Atelier became two things at once: an investigation site and a workshop.

Forensic accountants combed through records.

Renee interviewed designers.

Vanessa sat for hours answering questions about approvals she had signed.

Chloe learned to cut foam structure without destroying it.

She burned herself twice with a glue gun.

Maya did not laugh the second time.

Luis began receiving preliminary corrected royalty statements.

Priya discovered two of her masks had been licensed abroad without creator bonuses.

The company set aside reserve funds for restitution while counsel determined exact obligations.

Vanessa proposed selling one of the family’s investment properties to cover immediate payments if necessary.

That surprised Maya.

“You’d do that?”

Vanessa looked tired.

“It isn’t generosity. It’s responsibility.”

Progress.

Slow, expensive, humiliating progress.

Adrian remained missing.

Authorities began actively seeking him after evidence suggested possible fraud and document falsification.

No one declared him guilty.

But the evidence grew.

Then, four days before the rerun gala, Maya received a package.

No return address.

Inside was the missing original drive.

And a note.

Arthur trusted the wrong daughter.

Maya’s hands went cold.

She called Renee immediately.

The drive was preserved for forensic review without being plugged into any normal computer.

The handwriting did not match Adrian’s known samples.

Vanessa’s.

Chloe’s.

Marcus’s.

Unknown.

The next day investigators found a hidden email account linked to Adrian.

One message changed the case.

It was from someone inside the family.

Maya cannot control Bennett. She cares about artists more than leverage. Vanessa is easier. Chloe is easiest.

No signature.

But attached was an old internal family calendar available only through Vanessa’s office.

Maya looked at her stepmother.

Vanessa went pale.

“I didn’t send it.”

Maya wanted to believe her.

Chloe did.

Immediately.

“That’s not Mom.”

Maya looked at her.

“How do you know?”

“Because she would never write that Chloe is easiest.”

Vanessa almost laughed.

Chloe continued.

“She’d think it. She wouldn’t type it.”

Maya stared.

Then all three women began laughing.

It was inappropriate.

It was also the first moment they felt like family again.

Renee, less amused, traced access logs.

The message had been sent from Vanessa’s office terminal late at night six months before Arthur died.

Someone with building access.

Someone who knew the family intimately.

Marcus arrived while they were reviewing possibilities.

He read the email.

His face changed.

Maya noticed.

“You know.”

Marcus looked at Arthur’s photograph on the wall.

“I know who used to work from Vanessa’s office after hours.”

“Who?”

Marcus hesitated.

Then said a name Maya had not heard in years.

“Your father’s brother.”

Maya froze.

“Uncle Julian?”

May you like

92 The Girl They Called Broke Was a Billionaire’s Daughter—But Her Fathe...

91 A Cruel Hotel Manager Fired a Receptionist for Defending a Poor Old G...

90 On Christmas Eve, My Daughter-in-Law Stole $12,000 From My Card—Then...

Marcus nodded.

And suddenly the Bennett family scandal became larger than Adrian Cole.